What If the Haunted House Wants You to Stay?

I went to see Beauty and the Beast the other night (the stage musical, which is quite a bit different from the movies), and I came away thinking the Beast gets altogether too much credit for Belle staying.

The house did most of the work. Or, more accurately, the house and its memorable cast of implements. Which seems fair. If I’d had a dreadful first encounter with my host and the candlestick was the first person to make me feel welcome, I’d be inclined to hear the candlestick out.

It took me a while to realize that this is a haunted house story where I actually want the woman to stay in the house.

Think about it. She’s in a place she can’t leave. Things move that have no business moving. Voices come from objects that have no business talking. And everyone in the house has a keen personal interest in what she does next. Put all that in a horror novel and I’d be telling her to get the hell out of there. Here I’m thinking she should at least stay for dinner.

It helps that the people in the castle have been living with the Beast for years. They know what he’s like at breakfast. They know what happens when he’s in a temper. And they’re willing to give Belle the sort of welcome he’s singularly incapable of providing. They make it possible for her to spend enough time around him to see something beyond the dreadful first impression. Frankly, he owes them all a raise.

Of course, the household has a stake in the outcome. If Belle leaves, she gets to go home. They still have to be furniture. And that’s the bit I keep turning over. A haunted house can make you want to run by making it plain you’re unwelcome. This castle makes Belle want to be there by giving her people she’d miss. It also gives her an excellent library, which in my case would have bought the Beast considerably more time than he deserved.

I wonder how I’d feel about all that hospitality if I were Belle and knew exactly what the household stood to gain. I might still love the teapot. I might still stay for dinner. But if I mentioned going home and the candlestick asked whether I’d seen the library’s second floor, I’d start to wonder.

I’d go and look, obviously. Then I’d wonder.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top