Fantasy has a tendency to make magic remarkably tidy.
There are mages. There are non-mages. Perhaps the mages belong to a guild, or attend a school, or answer to the king. There are rules about who may practise magic, and possibly stern penalties for breaking those rules.
Everyone more or less understands what magic is, where it belongs in society, and how they feel about it. Which is very convenient.
I don’t think for a minute that this is what would happen if magic suddenly appeared in our world. I think it would be an absolute mess.
And, unexpectedly, we’re getting a pretty good demonstration of what that mess might look like right now.
Because AI isn’t magic, but the way human beings are reacting to AI may be the closest thing we’ve ever had to watching what would happen if someone announced, “Good news! We’ve discovered magic.”
Imagine Magic Appeared Tomorrow
Not a fantasy world in which magic has existed since antiquity. Ours. Tomorrow morning someone demonstrates, beyond any doubt, that magic works.
Perhaps it’s fairly limited at first. You can move objects without touching them. Heal certain injuries. Conjure images. Translate languages. Find lost objects. Alter the appearance of things. Whatever.
It doesn’t really matter what the first spells do. What matters is what happens next.
And I don’t think humanity would collectively say, “How marvellous. We shall now establish the Guild of Mages, construct a picturesque tower and agree upon a sensible set of rules.”
For one thing, governments wouldn’t even agree with each other. One country would ban magic. Another would subsidize it. A third would permit commercial magic but prohibit private use.
Someone would declare it a human right. Someone else would call it an existential threat. There would be international conferences, emergency legislation and politicians confidently explaining magical principles they clearly did not understand.
Meanwhile, businesses would be looking at their payrolls. If one magically assisted employee can do the work that previously required five people, how long before companies start requiring employees to use magic?
How long before a job advertisement says magical proficiency is “preferred”? How long before it’s mandatory?
And what happens to the employee who has profound ethical objections to magic and refuses to use it?
We’ve already started answering these questions. Just substitute AI for magic.
There Wouldn’t Be One Reaction to Magic
This is the part I think fantasy sometimes flattens. Magic changes the world, and therefore the world becomes a particular sort of place. But that’s not how disruptive change seems to work.
Look at AI.
Some people love it. Some loathe it. Some are frightened of it. Some are fascinated by it. Some regard it as morally indefensible. Some use it every day without giving the ethics of it five minutes’ thought.
Some employers ban it. Other employers require it.
Some people have become dramatically more productive because of it, including people with disabilities, neurodivergent people, and other demographic minorities. Other people have watched their professions change beneath their feet. Some have lost work.
Schools are trying to decide what constitutes cheating. Courts and governments are wrestling with laws written before the technology existed. Companies are discovering uses for it that weren’t envisioned a few years ago.
People are also discovering incredibly stupid uses for it, because we remain human. (AI toothbrushes, anyone?)
And none of this is happening in sequence. It’s all happening at once.
Now imagine that instead of generating text or images, the new disruptive technology could levitate a pallet of bricks. What happens to crane operators? What happens to workplace safety regulations?
Can anyone levitate the bricks, or does the person have to be certified? Will the insurance company cover the building if magically assisted construction was used?
Does a building inspector have to be magically qualified? Can the construction company require its workers to use levitation magic? Can a worker refuse? Can a union negotiate limits on magical labour?
And while legislators are still holding hearings about all of this, some guy in his backyard is levitating his above-ground swimming pool because he thinks it’s funny.
That’s the world I would expect.
Then We Get to Ownership
This is where things become particularly entertaining.
Who owns a spell? Can you copyright one? Patent it? Can a company own a spell discovered by one of its employees?
What if I teach you my spell and you modify it? What if a spell requires ingredients developed by someone else? What if you cast a spell using knowledge taken from thousands of other people’s work?
What if your spell can produce a painting? Who owns the painting?
I said AI isn’t magic. I didn’t say we wouldn’t end up having many of the same arguments. Publishing is already having them.
Writers, publishers, artists, editors, narrators and readers are trying to work out where the boundaries lie. Questions about copyright sit alongside questions about employment, ethics, disclosure, artistic legitimacy and what constitutes acceptable assistance.
Different organizations have come up with different rules. Different writers have drawn their lines in different places. Readers have their own opinions.
And because human beings are so wonderfully reasonable when questions of art, money, morality and identity collide, everyone is handling this calmly.
Obviously.
And Then Come the Witch Hunts
This is where the metaphor gets almost embarrassingly convenient. If magic suddenly existed, sooner or later someone would be accused of using it when they hadn’t.
“She couldn’t possibly have done that herself.”
“He must have used magic.”
“Look at this. You can tell.”
How?
Well.
You just can.
Publishing is already dealing with accusations of undisclosed AI use, including the much thornier problem of determining whether AI was actually involved.
AI detection is imperfect. Human detection is considerably more imperfect, especially when “I don’t like this” starts turning into “therefore it must have been made by a machine.”
If we had actual magic, we’d do exactly the same thing. We wouldn’t merely argue over whether magic should be permitted. We’d argue over whether somebody had secretly used it.
And somewhere there would be a perfectly innocent woman wondering why an angry mob was approaching her house carrying pitchforks.
We’ve apparently been rehearsing that part for centuries.
You’ll Know Magic Has Really Arrived When the Criminals and the Sex Industry Get Hold of It
There are two unofficial signs that a new technology has become part of ordinary human life: Criminals work out how to exploit it. And the sex industry works out what else you can do with it.
Neither group is famous for waiting patiently until regulators have established best practices.
If magic appeared tomorrow, criminals wouldn’t wait for Parliament to amend the Criminal Code. They’d be figuring out magical fraud, magical identity theft, enchanted contraband, ways around surveillance, counterfeit magical goods and probably several entirely new categories of crime for which we don’t yet have names.
Law enforcement would respond. Criminals would respond to the response. And away we’d go.
Meanwhile, someone would find a sexual application for magic approximately fifteen minutes after the first successful spell. Then someone else would monetize it. Then there would be arguments about exploitation, consent, safety and regulation.
Then someone would invent something so peculiar that the rest of us would collectively stare at it and ask why anyone had even thought of doing that.
Because magic wouldn’t change human nature. Human nature would change magic.
Most Magic Would Probably Be Boring
This may be the part I most want to see in fantasy. Once the novelty wore off, most people wouldn’t be using magic to overthrow kingdoms or summon demons. They’d be using it to get stains out of the carpet.
A plumber would have three extremely useful spells. Accountants would have developed magical applications nobody outside accounting understood. Restaurants would use magic for food preservation and pest control.
Parents would desperately want a spell that located missing shoes five minutes before school. Professional sports would have extremely detailed rules about which forms of magic constituted performance enhancement.
Casinos would have wards everywhere. Airports would add another irritating security procedure.
Someone would offer cheap magical services on Facebook Marketplace despite having no qualifications whatsoever.
And, yes, somewhere there would still be a wizard trying to seize control of the world.
But most of us would be far more concerned about whether the magically repaired washing machine was still covered by the manufacturer’s warranty.
Perhaps Our Fantasy Worlds Should Be Messier
None of this means that fantasy worlds with established magical systems don’t make sense. If magic has existed for thousands of years, of course societies will have built institutions around it. Laws, traditions, professions, religions and social expectations will have developed.
But even then, I suspect things should be messier than they sometimes are. Different cultures would regulate magic differently. Different religions would interpret it differently. Class would matter. Money would matter. Geography would matter.
Some industries would depend upon magic. Others would resist it. There would be ancient laws whose original purpose nobody remembered. There would be black markets.
There would be people practising magic illegally because the official route was too expensive.
There would be families who considered magic perfectly ordinary and other families who wouldn’t tolerate it under their roof.
And whenever a genuinely new form of magic appeared, the arguments would begin all over again.
If magic appeared for the first time? Then forget tidy. We’d be improvising.
Which is what makes watching our current encounter with AI so interesting from a fantasy point of view.
Whatever your own experience of AI has been—useful, infuriating, frightening, exciting, damaging, ridiculous or some complicated mixture of all of them—you’re getting a glimpse of what happens when human beings acquire a capability that society hasn’t yet figured out how to absorb.
The technology isn’t the interesting part. We are.
Fantasy has spent a very long time asking what people would do if magic were real. It turns out we may have been making our imaginary worlds far too simple.
.
.
Newly Released: Street Magic IV — After the Quieting. — Veilbound — Firebird Omnibus